Neonate Mystery

Step into the unknown with our Garage Sale Mystery Bait – the ultimate surprise for anglers who love the thrill of discovery. Each mystery pack is hand-selected from our rotating stash of baits that didn’t quite make it to our main lineup — but still pack serious fish-catching potential.

Think of it as a backstage pass to Supreme Lure Co. innovation: experimental colors, limited-run designs, overstock, or baits from discontinued batches. No two orders are the same, and you won’t find these exact selections anywhere else on the site.

🎁 What's inside? That's the mystery. But we guarantee it's worth more than you pay.

Available only under our brand-new Garage Sale section – once they're gone, they're gone.